Re: American Idol 4/1 (Liveblogged!)

Paul — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 21:39:55 -0000

Matt F. wrote:

What’s your problem with Jason? Every week you have him in the bottom 3.

He does okay, but he doesn't really stand out. It sounds a lot like the same performance every week. Other people I thought did better have been eliminated the last two weeks, so there are fewer people to take the fall for him.

I thought it was “Smoky Mountain Memories” instead of “Appalachin?”

Corrected.

-- Pauley

Re: American Idol 4/1 (Liveblogged!)

Matt F. — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 21:26:15 -0000

Fortunately for Brooke, she's well liked and there were 3 performances that were worse than hers. Brooke completely missed that song. It's a song about a woman telling another woman to leave her man alone not sheepishly pleading with her. Where was the anger at the other woman for even trying? Brooke is just too nice to sing a song like this.

Ramiele was flat out boring. She sounded fine, but it wasn't exciting.

Kristy Lee was the same. Sounded fine, but was just uninspiring. I think she could've picked a number of Dolly Parton songs and done better than this.

Syesha did well on the "Dolly" part of the song. When she tried to go Whitney, all she proved was she could hold notes for a long period of time. As you said, it was borderline off pitch.

What's your problem with Jason? Every week you have him in the bottom 3. I was surprised last week, but he was much better this week, so he should be safe. Replace him with Kristy Lee, in my opinion. I also agree that Ramiele is done. It's sad that this wasn't "Country Week" because I would've loved to see Ramiele do something from Martina McBride because she reminds me of her (small frame, huge voice).

I thought it was "Smoky Mountain Memories" instead of "Appalachin?"

Digital Brainwaves - Latest Comments in American Idol 4/1 (Liveblogged!)

Re: American Idol 4/1 (Liveblogged!)

Re: American Idol 4/1 (Liveblogged!)